Communitygithub.com

ericrisco/rsc-harness

用于判断短视频片段是否值得发布——根据十项加权标准对 Reel、Shorts 或播客片段进行评分(0-100),并自动扣分,然后对批次进行排序并标注截止点。在渲染前对候选转录本运行此工具。不编写钩子或标题(那是 `shortform-packaging` 的任务),不构思想法(那是 `shortform-ideation` 的任务),不执行剪辑(那是 `shortform-editing` 的任务)。

rsc-harness 是什么?

这是一个固定且客观的短视频片段评分系统,旨在评估垂直短片(如 Reel、Short 或播客片段)的传播潜力。其核心价值在于评分标准完全固定——相同的片段在周一和周五会得到相同的分数,不同片段之间可直接比较,因为使用同一套衡量标准。该技能通过十项加权标准(钩子、预期留存、情感冲击、可分享性、评论价值、信息清晰度、价值密度、原创性、上下文独立性、故事性)对片段进行0-10分评分,并自动应用七项叠加扣分项,最终将分数限制在0-100范围内。用户需要在渲染前对转录候选内容进行评分,而非对已渲染的视频进行评分。系统支持批量评分,能够生成排序列表并明确标注“发布/审查/丢弃”的截止点。它与其他短格式技能(打包、构思、剪辑、策略)配合使用,形成一个完整的工作流。该技能特别强调不要用自己的判断替代评分标准,不要调整权重,且要严格对待上下文独立性要求。

兼容平台✓Claude Code~Codex CLI~Cursor
npx skills add https://github.com/ericrisco/rsc-harness/tree/HEAD/skills/viral-score

在你喜欢的 AI 中提问

打开一个已预加载此 Agent Skill 的新对话。

文档

viral-score — 这个片段值得发布吗?

一个用于评估垂直短视频传播潜力的固定评分标准。其价值在于固定:同一个片段在周一和周五得分相同,两个片段之间可以比较,因为它们由同一套工具衡量。

因此,不要用自己的判断替代评分标准,也不要调整权重。 如果某个片段具有评分标准未包含的质量,请在理由中说明——但用本标准打分。

尽可能在渲染前对候选片段进行评分。对转录片段进行判断只需几秒钟;剪辑一个最终被丢弃的片段则要花费整个下午。

十项标准

每项按 0-10 分评分。

#标准权重得分的依据
1开场钩子20%前3秒能否抓住眼球?好奇心、惊喜、情绪、强烈主张、引人注目的开场
2预期留存20%是否有理由看到结尾?持续的好奇心、节奏、结局、无空白
3情感冲击15%强度:灵感、敬畏、恐惧、愤怒、喜悦、怀旧、幽默、惊喜。漠不关心得分极低
4可分享性10%有人会把它发给朋友吗?
5评论价值10%它是否引发争论或回复?
6信息清晰度5%想法能否用一句话概括?
7价值密度5%每秒的内容是否都有价值?
8原创性5%是否与众不同或出人意料?
9上下文独立性5%没有听过节目的其他部分是否能理解?
10故事性5%是否有故事、教训或转变?

计算方法

Viral Score = ( Hook×0.20 + Retention×0.20 + Emotion×0.15 + Shareability×0.10
              + Comments×0.10 + Clarity×0.05 + Density×0.05
              + Originality×0.05 + Context×0.05 + Storytelling×0.05 ) × 10

自动扣分

在公式计算完成后扣除,且可叠加。

扣分项扣分点数
钩子弱−10
开头缓慢−8
需要过多上下文−10
长时间停顿−5
想法过于普通−8
未激起任何情绪−10
结尾不满意−5

最终结果限制在 [0, 100] 范围内。

分数解读

分数范围结论
95-100优秀。立即发布
90-94很可能会表现出色
80-89不错的候选。值得编辑和发布
70-79可接受,但还有更好的片段
60-69较弱。除非别无选择,否则不发布
0-59丢弃

每个片段所需输出

  • 开始和结束时间戳
  • 病毒性得分(0-100)
  • 包含所有十项标准得分的表格
  • 评分理由
  • 主要优势
  • 主要劣势
  • 结论:发布 / 审查 / 丢弃

对多个片段进行评分会额外生成两项内容:从高到低的排名,以及截止点——即发布不再值得的分数界限。

如何正确应用

评价片段本身,而非其主题。 一个精彩的节目常常会产生一个得分只有45的片段。

根据实际的前三秒判断钩子,而不是抽象的想法。一个以填充词或句子中间开头的片段,其钩子较弱:−10。这也是为什么片段应该从句子边界开始剪辑——剪切点决定了钩子。

对上下文独立性要严格。 如果观众需要知道嘉宾是谁,或之前的问题是什么,则扣 −10。

不要拔高平均值。 如果二十个片段都高于80分,则说明评分标准没有被正确应用。一个健康的批次应该分布广泛,极少有高于85分的。

为每个低分提供片段中的具体证据,包括时间戳,而不是笼统的陈述。

反模式

反模式正确做法
评价主题多么有趣评价这个片段的执行;主题并非产物
根据整体想法给钩子打分只阅读前三秒,像观众那样接收
将批次分数压缩在78-85之间使用整个分数区间;分布平坦意味着工具未被使用
“钩子弱”但没有证据引用开场词和时间戳
为了喜欢的片段调整权重权重就是工具。在理由中论证,用评分标准打分
先渲染,后评分对转录候选评分,然后只编辑通过的片段
因为总分看起来低而跳过扣分扣分是自动且可叠加的;一个72分的片段加上三个扣分项后是49分

参见

  • ../shortform-packaging/SKILL.md — 通过此标准的片段的钩子、标题、话题标签和封面。
  • ../shortform-ideation/SKILL.md — 构思角度,这是评分之前的上游工作。
  • ../shortform-editing/SKILL.md — 选定片段后的剪辑执行。
  • ../shortform-strategy/SKILL.md — 频道长期应该发布什么内容,此工具提供每个片段的证据。

Individual skills in this repo

This repo contains 9 individual skills — each has its own dedicated page.

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when writing the words on a single conversion page — the hero headline and subhead, the offer, the proof and testimonials, and one primary CTA — or diagnosing a page that gets traffic and does not convert, as a copy problem rather than a layout one. NOT the paid ad that drives the click (that is `ads`), NOT the visual layout the words sit in (that is `design`), NOT the experiment that picks the winning variant (that is `ab-testing`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when you need to render an actual video file with Remotion — React compositions, the Composition/Sequence/TransitionSeries graph, transitions, burned-in word-by-word captions from a transcript, automatic silence removal, b-roll overlays, headless CI renders, and a final MP4 or MOV. NOT writing the script, hook, beats or caption text (that is `video-shorts`), NOT mastering audio to LUFS or building an RSS feed (that is `podcast`), NOT structuring the narrative arc (that is `course-storytelling`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when you have raw 9:16 footage and need it cut into a post-ready vertical short — dead air removed, fast jump cuts, karaoke word-by-word burned-in captions from a transcript, cuts and zooms snapped to the music beat, safe-area placement so captions clear the platform UI, and a platform-correct MP4 export. NOT writing the script, hook, beats or caption text (that is `video-shorts`), NOT building a Remotion React composition codebase (that is `remotion-video`), NOT deciding when or where to post (that is `social-publisher`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when a Reels/TikTok/Shorts account needs its next video ideas scored into a ranked backlog, grounded in its own performance log plus dated trending sounds, each bet logged so its outcome feeds the next batch. NOT scripting a chosen idea (that is `video-shorts`), NOT pillars or cadence (that is `shortform-strategy`), NOT packaging a finished cut (that is `shortform-packaging`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when a vertical short is shot or scripted and you need the upload-form copy and cover that win the feed — the hook line, the first-frame on-screen text, the search-led caption, a tight hashtag set, and the cover frame; it learns from what performed via the 02-DOCS log. NOT inventing the idea (that is `shortform-ideation`), NOT scripting or directing the cuts (that is `video-shorts`), NOT executing the edit (that is `shortform-editing`), NOT scheduling the post (that is `social-publisher`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when the unit of work is a TikTok/Reels account, not one clip: positioning, sustainable cadence and format mix, ride-or-skip on a trend or sound, recurring series, diagnosing a flat account, and the dated learning loop. NOT the single script or hook variants (that is `video-shorts`), NOT the idea backlog (that is `shortform-ideation`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when planning a posting schedule, building a multi-platform content calendar, or reshaping one source asset into channel-native posts across X, LinkedIn, Instagram, Threads, Bluesky, TikTok, Facebook or YouTube — cadence, best-time slots, per-platform format limits, API publish caps, and a dated CSV or JSON calendar a scheduler can import. NOT the brand voice the posts speak in (that is `brand-voice`), NOT the editorial strategy of what to make (that is `content-engine`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when connecting a real TikTok account to code via the Content Posting, Display and Business Account APIs — OAuth, chunked video publish with status polling, and pulling views, watch time and impression sources, then logging that performance into the wiki as a dated feedback record. Covers short-lived tokens breaking a cron, unverified pull-from-URL ownership, and rate limits. NOT what to post or how to package it (that is `shortform-strategy` and `shortform-packaging`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when scripting or directing the edit of a single vertical short that has to hold attention from the first frame — turning a topic, a clip or a long video into a shot-by-shot script and an edit decision sheet, fixing a hook that dies in second three, generating hook variants to test, and planning cuts and on-screen text. NOT scheduling or cross-platform cadence (that is `social-publisher`), NOT running the editorial calendar (that is `content-engine`), NOT defining the durable brand tone (that is `brand-voice`).

相关技能