Communitygithub.com

ericrisco/rsc-harness

用於判斷短影音片段是否值得發布——根據十項加權標準對 Reels、Shorts 或 podcast 片段進行 0-100 評分,並自動扣分,然後對批次進行排名並標示 cutoff 門檻。在渲染前對腳本候選進行評分。不負責撰寫鉤子或標題(那是 `shortform-packaging` 的範疇),不構思創意(那是 `shortform-ideation` 的範疇),也不執行剪輯(那是 `shortform-editing` 的範疇)。

rsc-harness 是什麼?

這是 `viral-score` 技能(位於 `ericrisco/rsc-harness`),它提供一個固定的評分框架,用於客觀評估垂直短影音片段(如 Instagram Reels、YouTube Shorts 或 podcast 精華)的傳播潛力。其核心價值在於評分標準的固定性:同一個片段在星期一和星期五會得到相同分數,且兩個片段之間可直接比較。技能使用十項加權標準(開場鉤子 20%、預期留存率 20%、情感衝擊 15% 等),每項 0-10 分,透過線性公式計算基礎分數,再疊加自動扣分(如弱鉤子 −10、需要過多背景 −10),最終結果限制在 [0, 100] 範圍內。對於每個片段,它要求輸出時間戳記、病毒分數、所有標準評分表、評分理由、主要優勢、主要劣勢以及裁決(發布/審查/丟棄)。當評估多個片段時,它還會提供從高到低的排名,並指出不再值得發布的 cutoff 點。此技能適用於 Claude Code、Codex 等 AI 編碼代理,開發者或內容創作者可在渲染前對腳本候選進行評分,避免浪費編輯時間在低品質剪輯上。它明確與 `shortform-packaging`(撰寫鉤子與標題)、`shortform-ideation`(構思創意)、`shortform-editing`(執行剪輯)和 `shortform-strategy`(頻道策略)等其他技能區分開來。

相容平台✓Claude Code~Codex CLI~Cursor
npx skills add https://github.com/ericrisco/rsc-harness/tree/HEAD/skills/viral-score

在你喜歡的 AI 中提問

開啟一個已預先載入此 Agent Skill 的新對話。

說明文件

viral-score — 這個片段值得發布嗎?

一個固定的評分規則,用於評估垂直短影音片段的傳播潛力。其價值在於它固定不變:同一個片段在星期一和星期五會得到相同分數,兩個片段也可互相比較,因為它們是用同一套工具測量的。

所以不要用你自己的判斷取代這套規則,也不要調整權重。 如果某個片段具有規則未涵蓋的品質,請在理由中說明——但請使用此規則進行評分。

盡可能在渲染之前對候選片段進行評分。判斷一段文字稿只需要幾秒鐘;而編輯一個最終被捨棄的片段則會耗費整個下午。

十項標準

每項評分範圍為 0-10。

#標準權重何時獲得高分
1開場鉤子20%前 3 秒能否停止滑動?好奇心、驚喜、情緒、強烈主張、引人注目的開場
2預期留存率20%是否有理由看到結尾?持續的好奇心、節奏、解決方案、無冷場
3情感衝擊15%強度:啟發、敬畏、恐懼、憤怒、喜悅、懷舊、幽默、驚喜。冷漠會得到非常低的分數
4可分享性10%是否有人會將此傳給朋友?
5評論價值10%是否引發辯論或回覆?
6訊息清晰度5%這個想法是否能濃縮成一句話?
7價值密度5%每秒鐘是否都值得?
8原創性5%是否與眾不同或出乎意料?
9背景獨立性5%是否不需要聽完節目其餘部分就能理解?
10故事性5%是否有故事、教訓或轉變?

計算方式

病毒分數 = ( 鉤子×0.20 + 留存率×0.20 + 情感×0.15 + 可分享性×0.10
              + 評論價值×0.10 + 清晰度×0.05 + 密度×0.05
              + 原創性×0.05 + 背景×0.05 + 故事性×0.05 ) × 10

自動扣分

在公式計算之後扣除,且可疊加。

扣分項目分數
開場鉤子弱−10
開場節奏緩慢−8
需要過多背景知識−10
長時間停頓−5
想法過於普通−8
無法引發情感−10
結尾不令人滿意−5

將最終結果限制在 [0, 100] 範圍內。

分數解讀

範圍裁決
95-100卓越。立即發布
90-94極有可能表現良好
80-89不錯的候選。值得編輯並發布
70-79可接受,但有更好的片段
60-69弱。只有在別無選擇時才發布
0-59丟棄

每個片段必備輸出

  • 開始和結束時間戳記
  • 病毒分數(0-100)
  • 包含所有十項標準分數的表格
  • 評分背後的理由
  • 主要優勢
  • 主要弱點
  • 裁決:發布 / 審查 / 丟棄

評分多個片段時會增加兩項內容:從高到低的排名,以及 cutoff 門檻所在的位置——低於這個點就不再值得發布。

如何善用此規則

評分的是片段,而不是主題。 一個精彩的節目單集,其片段可能只得到 45 分。

根據實際的前三秒來判斷鉤子,而不是抽象的想法。如果片段以填充詞或一句話的中間部分開場,那就是弱鉤子:−10。這也是為什麼片段應該從句子邊界開始剪輯——你的剪輯點決定了鉤子。

對背景獨立性要嚴格。 如果觀眾需要知道來賓是誰,或前一個問題是什麼,那就是 −10。

不要拉高平均分。 如果二十個片段都高於 80 分,那就代表沒有正確使用此規則。健康的批次應該分散分布,只有少數高於 85 分。

每個低分都要用片段的具體內容來佐證,並給出時間戳記——而不是泛泛而談。

反模式

反模式正確做法
評分主題本身有多有趣評分這個片段的執行方式;主題不是成品
根據整體想法來評分鉤子只讀取前 3 秒,如同觀眾所看到的那樣
將一批片段的分數壓縮在 78-85 之間善用分數範圍;分數分布平坦表示沒有使用好這套工具
「鉤子弱」卻沒有證據引用開場詞語和時間戳記
為自己喜歡的片段調整權重權重就是測量工具。在理由中論述,用規則來評分
先渲染,再評分先對文字稿候選進行評分,然後只編輯通過的片段
因為總分看起來很低就跳過扣分它們是自動且可疊加的;一個 72 分加上三個扣分就是 49

相關技能

  • ../shortform-packaging/SKILL.md — 為通過此門檻的片段撰寫鉤子行、標題、Hashtags 和封面。
  • ../shortform-ideation/SKILL.md — 在可評分的上游階段,構思切入點。
  • ../shortform-editing/SKILL.md — 一旦選定片段後,執行剪輯。
  • ../shortform-strategy/SKILL.md — 頻道在時間軸上應該發布什麼內容,此技能以每個片段的證據為其提供輸入。

Individual skills in this repo

This repo contains 9 individual skills — each has its own dedicated page.

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when writing the words on a single conversion page — the hero headline and subhead, the offer, the proof and testimonials, and one primary CTA — or diagnosing a page that gets traffic and does not convert, as a copy problem rather than a layout one. NOT the paid ad that drives the click (that is `ads`), NOT the visual layout the words sit in (that is `design`), NOT the experiment that picks the winning variant (that is `ab-testing`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when you need to render an actual video file with Remotion — React compositions, the Composition/Sequence/TransitionSeries graph, transitions, burned-in word-by-word captions from a transcript, automatic silence removal, b-roll overlays, headless CI renders, and a final MP4 or MOV. NOT writing the script, hook, beats or caption text (that is `video-shorts`), NOT mastering audio to LUFS or building an RSS feed (that is `podcast`), NOT structuring the narrative arc (that is `course-storytelling`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when you have raw 9:16 footage and need it cut into a post-ready vertical short — dead air removed, fast jump cuts, karaoke word-by-word burned-in captions from a transcript, cuts and zooms snapped to the music beat, safe-area placement so captions clear the platform UI, and a platform-correct MP4 export. NOT writing the script, hook, beats or caption text (that is `video-shorts`), NOT building a Remotion React composition codebase (that is `remotion-video`), NOT deciding when or where to post (that is `social-publisher`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when a Reels/TikTok/Shorts account needs its next video ideas scored into a ranked backlog, grounded in its own performance log plus dated trending sounds, each bet logged so its outcome feeds the next batch. NOT scripting a chosen idea (that is `video-shorts`), NOT pillars or cadence (that is `shortform-strategy`), NOT packaging a finished cut (that is `shortform-packaging`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when a vertical short is shot or scripted and you need the upload-form copy and cover that win the feed — the hook line, the first-frame on-screen text, the search-led caption, a tight hashtag set, and the cover frame; it learns from what performed via the 02-DOCS log. NOT inventing the idea (that is `shortform-ideation`), NOT scripting or directing the cuts (that is `video-shorts`), NOT executing the edit (that is `shortform-editing`), NOT scheduling the post (that is `social-publisher`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when the unit of work is a TikTok/Reels account, not one clip: positioning, sustainable cadence and format mix, ride-or-skip on a trend or sound, recurring series, diagnosing a flat account, and the dated learning loop. NOT the single script or hook variants (that is `video-shorts`), NOT the idea backlog (that is `shortform-ideation`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when planning a posting schedule, building a multi-platform content calendar, or reshaping one source asset into channel-native posts across X, LinkedIn, Instagram, Threads, Bluesky, TikTok, Facebook or YouTube — cadence, best-time slots, per-platform format limits, API publish caps, and a dated CSV or JSON calendar a scheduler can import. NOT the brand voice the posts speak in (that is `brand-voice`), NOT the editorial strategy of what to make (that is `content-engine`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when connecting a real TikTok account to code via the Content Posting, Display and Business Account APIs — OAuth, chunked video publish with status polling, and pulling views, watch time and impression sources, then logging that performance into the wiki as a dated feedback record. Covers short-lived tokens breaking a cron, unverified pull-from-URL ownership, and rate limits. NOT what to post or how to package it (that is `shortform-strategy` and `shortform-packaging`).

ericrisco/rsc-harness

Use when scripting or directing the edit of a single vertical short that has to hold attention from the first frame — turning a topic, a clip or a long video into a shot-by-shot script and an edit decision sheet, fixing a hook that dies in second three, generating hook variants to test, and planning cuts and on-screen text. NOT scheduling or cross-platform cadence (that is `social-publisher`), NOT running the editorial calendar (that is `content-engine`), NOT defining the durable brand tone (that is `brand-voice`).

相關技能