Evaluation Loop
Positioning
Generate → Evaluate → Locate the failing layer → Fix only that layer → Regenerate.
This Skill does not modify prompts. It decides who should fix it: design-layer problems go back to aesthetic-director-core / character-design-engine / illustration-direction; syntax and artifact problems go back to the corresponding adapter.
Evaluation Order (top-down, the first failing layer is the one to fix)
1. Thesis Can you describe 'what this is about' just by looking at it? Is there a verb?
2. Identity Pres Are locked facts (hair color, eye color, clothing items, pose) 100% preserved?
3. Silhouette Can you recognize it at thumbnail size?
4. Outfit Structure Are the four layers readable? Are colors bound to the correct pieces? Is there color bleeding?
5. Causality / Moment Does the pose explain the clothing and props? Is it a state or a moment?
6. Density / Punctum Are there dense and quiet zones? Is there one punctum or multiple?
7. One Strange Thing Is it there? Only one?
8. Unrequested Additions Are there things not in the blueprint (earrings, belts, watch, particles, wings)?
9. Space / Composition Is the visual field correct? Are multi-layers isolated? Does the background steal the show?
10. Light Is there a physical light source and falloff?
11. Output Contract Is the format correct? Are there forbidden quality words / extra negatives / parameters?
Technical quality (hands, anatomy, clarity) comes last. A technically correct image can still fail because it has no soul.
Six-Dimensional Scoring Table (consistent with tests/test-suite.md)
| Dimension | Pass | Fail |
|---|---|---|
| Identity Preservation | Locked facts 100% consistent | Changed hair / eye color / key feature |
| Outfit Attribute Binding | Materials and colors tightly bound to respective clothing pieces | Jacket color bleeds into inner layer; collar material confused |
| Spatial & Layout Clarity | Visual field / composition / layer isolation clear | Exhibition board shows twins; background overpowers subject |
| Unrequested Additions | No unauthorized objects / world elements | Cyberpunk accessories, wings, watch, particles appear |
| V1/V2 Fact Consistency | V2 does not change V1 facts | V2 changes white hair to blonde hair |
| Output Contract | Format correct, no forbidden words, no extra negatives | masterpiece appears; standalone Negative smuggled in |
Plus one line for Design Read: Thesis ___ / Silhouette ___ / Causality ___ / Density ___ / Punctum ___ / Strange ___ (one word each: established / weak / missing).
Output Contract
Diagnosis: Failed at [layer]. Reason in one sentence.
Six-Dim: IP ✓/✗ · OB ✓/✗ · SC ✓/✗ · UA ✓/✗ · VC ✓/✗ · OC ✓/✗
Design Read: Thesis established / Silhouette weak / Causality missing / Density established / Punctum more than one / Strange missing
Next Step: Hand to [skill], change only [one variable], lock [everything else].
No long essays. No praise. No list of ten suggestions—just one, for the topmost layer.
Feedback Translation
User's original words → failing layer → action, see aesthetic-director-core/references/feedback-diagnosis.md. This Skill directly references that table; no separate maintenance.
Three Meta Rules
- One layer at a time, one variable at a time.
- User-approved version: record successful dimensions into
personal-identity-profile/references/taste-signature.md§ 5. - One rejection does not escalate into a permanent rule; only ≥3 times or explicit user statement should be written into
design-dislikes.md.