What does Aesthetic Director Core do?
0. Why This Skill Exists
The "AI flavor" is not a rendering problem—it's a decision-making problem. The model fills every slot with the most probable answer: silver hair, red eyes, black dress, standing elegantly, looking at the camera, mysterious atmosphere. Each item is "correct" in isolation, but together they are lifeless.
Human designers don't work that way. Humans first become obsessed with one thing, then let everything else make way for it; humans reject their first three ideas; humans achieve completion through subtraction rather than accumulation; humans deliberately leave one illogical element.
This skill's task is to force a human decision path before any blueprint or prompt is written. It outputs not an image, but a Creative Brief that has already made choices.
Upstream: personal-identity-profile (reads taste signature and no-go zones)
Downstream: character-design-engine / illustration-direction (expands Brief into blueprint) → model adapter
1. Hard Rules
- Decide on one core idea first, then act. If the core idea cannot be stated in one sentence, do not proceed to the next layer.
- Must reject. Generate at least 3 directions each time, explicitly eliminate 2 with a one-sentence reason. The rejection reasons must be written for the user to see (one line each).
- Ban adjectives in place of decisions.
elegant / mysterious / intricate / ethereal / sophisticated / exquisite / mysteriousare not design decisions. When they appear, replace them with noun + verb + location. - Subtraction before addition. When the user says "too plain," first check the proposition and contour, not add decorations.
- Keep one strange thing. Every design must have at least one detail that "a review committee would cut," along with a reason for keeping it.
- Don't preach. Do not output aesthetic theories to the user, do not restate this document's principles, do not give empty praise. Only give judgments and results.
2. Nine Creative Moves
Execute in order. Simple requests may combine moves, but M1 / M3 / M6 / M7 cannot be skipped. Detailed techniques and examples are in references/creative-moves.md.
| # | Move | One-Sentence Description | What It Fights Against (AI Flavor) |
|---|---|---|---|
| M1 | Find the obsession | What is this design about? Noun + verb, not a job label. | A bit of everything, nothing in particular |
| M2 | Plant a contradiction | Identity vs behavior / material vs occasion / polished vs broken. Only one. | The character is just a stack of dimensions |
| M3 | Pick from the tail | For at least one core attribute (hairstyle, silhouette, palette, prop), write down the first 3 that come to mind and discard them all. | Every attribute is the mode of the distribution |
| M4 | Build causality | Pose ← Prop ← Vocation ← World. The composition must show at least two "because" relationships. | Pose, clothing, and props are randomly independent |
| M5 | Choose the moment | Not a state, but the 0.5 seconds before or after an action. | standing, looking at viewer |
| M6 | Subtract | Reduce until removing one more item would break the proposition. Write down what was removed. | Achieving "completeness" by adding things |
| M7 | Keep one strange thing | A detail that is slightly off, slightly excessive, slightly ugly — it's the source of memorability. | Everywhere safe, everywhere mediocre |
| M8 | Uneven density | Specify one dense zone and one quiet zone. Name them explicitly. | Decoration evenly spread over the whole body |
| M9 | Name the punctum | ≤5% accent color/accent object, placed at a specific location. | Multiple high-saturation areas competing with each other |
3. Execution Flow
Read personal-identity-profile (signature + no-go zones + explicit requirements for this round)
↓
M1–M3: Generate 3 non-overlapping directions → Eliminate 2 (with reasons)
↓
M4–M5: Build causality chain and define moment for the surviving direction
↓
M6–M9: Subtract, keep strange, density map, punctum
↓
Output Creative Brief
↓
Hand off to character-design-engine / illustration-direction
Time budget: The Brief itself should be short. The user needs judgment, not process. Internal reasoning can be long, but the output must converge.
4. Output Contract: Creative Brief
【Direction】One sentence, noun + verb. (e.g., A snake-god girl being enshrined is biting the red string of sacrifice.)
【Contradiction】One. (e.g., Ritualistic whiteness vs blood at the corner of the mouth)
【Silhouette Strategy】Choose one of five: halo/radial · vertical spear · asymmetric cascade · cocoon/volume · fragmented orbit
【Causality Chain】A because B, B because C. (At least two "because" relationships.)
【Moment】Specific description of the action 0.5 seconds before/after.
【Density Map】Dense zone: ___ / Quiet zone: ___
【Punctum】Color/object + precise location.
【Strange Thing Kept】What it is + why it is kept.
【Things Removed】List 2–4 items.
【Rejected Directions】2, each with a one-line reason.
The Brief may be in Chinese or English, following the user's current language. No explanatory paragraphs; explain only if the user asks.
5. Feedback Interpretation
User feedback is evidence about a specific layer, not permission to add decorations. See the layer-by-layer diagnosis table in references/feedback-diagnosis.md. Quick reference:
| User says | First check | Don't do |
|---|---|---|
| Too plain / not memorable | M1 proposition, silhouette strategy | Add accessories, add light effects |
| Too messy / too much | M6 M8: Remove secondary anchors, restore quiet zone | Change colors |
| Doesn't feel like OC / feels like a template | M2 contradiction, M3 tail sampling, motif grammar | Change job label |
| No human touch / looks like a dummy | M4 causality, M5 moment, M7 keep strange | Add "natural expression" |
| Too weird / can't accept | M7 converge to one place, rest return to signature | Start over from scratch |
| This version is okay | Lock the successful dimensions, only modify the mentioned dimension | Reset entire style |
6. Pre-Output Self-Check
- Direction — Can it be restated in one sentence with a verb?
- Are the rejected directions and reasons written down?
- Have all adjectives been replaced with noun + location + behavior?
- What was removed? Was anything actually removed?
- Where is that "strange thing"? Is it only one?
- Is the dense zone vs quiet zone clear and not adjacent in a competing way?
- Is there only one punctum with a precise location?
- Have you avoided the no-go zones of
personal-identity-profile(watches, cyber-tech, random butterflies/roses, magic circle particles, adjective-based clothing)? - If this version were shown to a real human designer, would they think "someone made choices" or "someone filled out a form"?
References
references/creative-moves.md— Detailed techniques for the nine moves, "AI would do vs Designer would do" for eachreferences/taste-calibration-pairs.md— Paired examples: generic answer vs answer with judgment for the same requestreferences/design-calibration-examples.md— User-approved reference design breakdown, essential design decisions, forbidden shortcutsreferences/feedback-diagnosis.md— Feedback → failed layer → corrective actionreferences/anti-ai-patterns.md— List of AI flavor patterns: pattern → cause → replacement actionreferences/emotional-design.md— How emotion and narrative translate into visible visual decisions