Community研究与数据分析github.com

zernie/analyze-sibling-paper

Deep-analyze a specific related / competing / concurrent paper — reading the ACTUAL paper, not its abstract — to decide the "isn't this just X?" question before a reviewer asks it: what it really does, whether it's prior or concurrent work, the strongest scoop a reviewer could claim, whether your delta is REAL or merely cosmetic, and the exact cite + positioning clause (or a scoop escalation) to apply. Saves the analysis to the paper's research folder and surfaces action points. Use whenever a paper close enough to yours surfaces — via verify-citations' nearest-neighbor, a reviewer's "this was already done", your own lit search, or an arXiv alert. Distinct from verify-citations (confirms a cite is real + one-line delta) and study-accepted-papers (mines a venue's accepted corpus for levers); this one does the deep per-competitor overlap/scoop analysis. Compose with verify-citations (feeds it neighbors), harden-paper (its nearest-neighbor-scoop axis calls this), and extend-paper (a scooped angle can become the

analyze-sibling-paper 是什么?

analyze-sibling-paper is a Claude Code agent skill that deep-analyze a specific related / competing / concurrent paper — reading the ACTUAL paper, not its abstract — to decide the "isn't this just X?" question before a reviewer asks it: what it really does, whether it's prior or concurrent work, the strongest scoop a reviewer could claim, whether your delta is REAL or merely cosmetic, and the exact cite + positioning clause (or a scoop escalation) to apply. Saves the analysis to the paper's research folder and surfaces action points. Use whenever a paper close enough to yours surfaces — via verify-citations' nearest-neighbor, a reviewer's "this was already done", your own lit search, or an arXiv alert. Distinct from verify-citations (confirms a cite is real + one-line delta) and study-accepted-papers (mines a venue's accepted corpus for levers); this one does the deep per-competitor overlap/scoop analysis. Compose with verify-citations (feeds it neighbors), harden-paper (its nearest-neighbor-scoop axis calls this), and extend-paper (a scooped angle can become the.

兼容平台~Claude Code~Codex CLI~Cursor
npx skills add https://github.com/zernie/research-paper-pipeline/tree/main/skills/analyze-sibling-paper

Installed? Explore more 研究与数据分析 skills: obra/superpowers, affaan-m/quarkus-verification, affaan-m/uspto-database · View all 6 →

在你喜欢的 AI 中提问

打开一个已预加载此 Agent Skill 的新对话。

文档

analyze-sibling-paper 是做什么的?

Deep-analyze a specific related / competing / concurrent paper — reading the ACTUAL paper, not its abstract — to decide the "isn't this just X?" question before a reviewer asks it: what it really does, whether it's prior or concurrent work, the strongest scoop a reviewer could claim, whether your delta is REAL or merely cosmetic, and the exact cite + positioning clause (or a scoop escalation) to apply. Saves the analysis to the paper's research folder and surfaces action points. Use whenever a paper close enough to yours surfaces — via verify-citations' nearest-neighbor, a reviewer's "this was already done", your own lit search, or an arXiv alert. Distinct from verify-citations (confirms a cite is real + one-line delta) and study-accepted-papers (mines a venue's accepted corpus for levers); this one does the deep per-competitor overlap/scoop analysis. Compose with verify-citations (feeds it neighbors), harden-paper (its nearest-neighbor-scoop axis calls this), and extend-paper (a scooped angle can become the

相关技能