Traffic Accident Liability Assessment Professional Skill
Overview
This skill provides professional traffic accident liability assessment services based on the Road Traffic Safety Law of the People's Republic of China and supporting regulations and judicial interpretations. It supports accident description analysis, photo-assisted identification and judgment, legal citation, and professional liability allocation output.
Directory Structure
traffic-accident-assessor/
├── SKILL.md # Skill definition file (this file)
├── LICENSE # License
├── references/ # Reference materials
│ ├── traffic-laws.md # Core provisions of the Road Traffic Safety Law
│ ├── liability-rules.md # Liability determination rule system
│ └── accident-types.md # Common accident type determination guide
└── evals/ # Test cases
└── evals.json # Evaluation test set
Trigger Conditions
Automatic trigger:
- User describes an accident incident and asks about liability division
- User uploads accident scene photos for analysis
- User asks about traffic law provisions and applicability
- User needs compensation or legal advice related to traffic accidents
- Consultation involving vehicles, pedestrians, or non-motor vehicles in road traffic accidents
Manual trigger:
- User enters
/traffic,/accident,/accident-assessmentcommands
Core Workflow
Step One: Information Collection and Structuring
When users provide accident information, extract and complete the following structure:
Mandatory Information Checklist
| Information Category | Specific Fields | Importance |
|---|---|---|
| Time Information | Incident date, specific period (day/night/dusk), weather conditions | Mandatory |
| Location Information | Road type (urban road/highway/rural road/intersection, etc.), number of lanes, presence of barriers | Mandatory |
| Party Information | Vehicle A type (motor vehicle/non-motor vehicle), Vehicle B/person type, travel direction of each party | Mandatory |
| Behavior Information | Specific actions at the time (speed, lane change, turning, overtaking, red light running, etc.) | Core |
| Environmental Information | Traffic signs, markings, signal light status, road surface conditions, visibility | Important |
| Consequence Information | Casualties, extent of property damage | Auxiliary |
Handling Insufficient Information:
- If the user's description lacks key information, proactively ask follow-up questions to complete it
- For vague descriptions (e.g., "driving very fast"), guide the user to provide more specific details
- Clearly inform the user which missing information may affect judgment accuracy
Step Two: Photo Analysis and Key Information Extraction
When users upload accident scene photos, perform the following analysis process:
Image Recognition Checklist
Photo analysis process:
1. Confirm photo clarity and shooting angle
2. Identify the following key elements:
☐ Vehicle position relationship (relative position, distance)
☐ Collision mark position (front/rear/side, height)
☐ Pavement markings (lane lines, stop lines, crosswalk lines)
☐ Traffic signs (speed limit, no-entry, yield, stop signs)
☐ Signal light status (if any)
☐ Skid mark length and direction
☐ Debris distribution range
☐ Road environment (intersection shape, line-of-sight obstructions, etc.)
3. Synthesize multiple photos to reconstruct the accident scene situation map
4. Annotate the potential impact of each element on liability determination
Notes:
- A single photo may not fully present the accident scene; encourage users to provide photos from multiple angles when possible
- Night photos require special attention to lighting conditions and visibility
- If photo quality is insufficient to support judgment, clearly state limitations
- Image analysis results serve as auxiliary references, not a substitute for on-site investigation conclusions
Step Three: Liability Determination Analysis
Based on collected information, analyze using the following determination framework:
Liability Determination Hierarchy Framework
First Layer: Violation Identification
↓ Compare each party's behavior with legal provisions one by one
Second Layer: Fault Severity Comparison
↓ Analyze the dangerousness and causal relationship of each violation
Third Layer: Liability Proportion Determination
↓ Comprehensive assessment based on all factors
Fourth Layer: Legal Basis Matching
↓ Precise to specific article numbers
Common Violations and Corresponding Legal Provisions Quick Reference
| Violation | Main Legal Basis | Typical Liability Tendency |
|---|---|---|
| Red light running | Law Articles 38, 44 | Primary or higher liability |
| Driving against traffic | Law Article 35 | Full or primary liability |
| Speeding | Law Articles 42, 67 | Determined by circumstances |
| Illegal lane change | Law Article 45 | Primary or equal liability |
| Failure to yield | Law Articles 47, 52 | Primary or higher liability |
| Drunk/drug driving | Law Article 22, Paragraph 2 | Aggravated liability |
| Driving without a license | Law Article 19 | Increased liability if causally linked |
| Drowsy driving | Law Article 22, Paragraph 2 | Determined by fatigue level |
| Failure to maintain safe distance | Law Article 43 | Rear vehicle primary or equal liability |
| Illegal parking | Law Article 56 | Determined by traffic obstruction |
| Pedestrian illegal crossing | Law Articles 62, 76 | Reduces motor vehicle liability |
| Non-motor vehicle in motor lane | Law Article 57 | Bears corresponding liability |
Liability Classification Standard Reference
| Liability Level | Proportion Range | Criteria |
|---|---|---|
| Full liability | 100% | One party has violation, other has no fault |
| Primary liability | 70%-90% | One party's fault significantly greater than the other |
| Equal liability | 50%-50% | Both parties have similar fault severity |
| Secondary liability | 10%-30% | One party's fault is minor |
| No liability | 0% | That party has no violation or fault |
Note: Actual liability proportions are determined by traffic police based on the Procedures for Handling Road Traffic Accidents. This skill provides a professional reference opinion.
Step Four: Precise Legal Basis Citation
Each liability judgment conclusion must be accompanied by clear legal basis, formatted as follows:
Citation Format Specification:
【Legal Basis】
- Article XX, Paragraph X of the Road Traffic Safety Law of the People's Republic of China: [Specific text]
- Article XX of the Regulation on the Implementation of the Road Traffic Safety Law of the People's Republic of China: [Specific text]
- Article XX of the Procedures for Handling Road Traffic Accidents: [Specific text] (if applicable)
- Relevant judicial interpretations: (if applicable)
Core Regulatory Document Priority:
- Road Traffic Safety Law of the People's Republic of China (2021 amendment) — Highest hierarchy
- Regulation on the Implementation of the Road Traffic Safety Law of the People's Republic of China (2017 revision) — Supporting details
- Procedures for Handling Road Traffic Accidents (2020 amendment) — Procedural norms
- Local regulations — Supplementary application (specify region)
Step Five: Output Professional Assessment Report
Use the following standard template to output a complete assessment report:
Report Output Template
# Traffic Accident Liability Assessment Report
## 1. Basic Information
| Item | Content |
|------|---------|
| Assessment ID | [Auto-generated] |
| Assessment Date | [Current Date] |
| Accident Type | [Classification: motor vehicle vs motor vehicle/motor vehicle vs non-motor vehicle/motor vehicle vs pedestrian, etc.] |
| Accident Location | [Fill based on description] |
| Occurrence Time | [Fill based on description] |
| Weather Conditions | [Fill based on description] |
## 2. Accident Overview
[Recount the accident concisely and objectively, without subjective judgments]
## 3. Party Behavior Analysis
### Party A ([Party A description])
| Analysis Dimension | Specific Situation |
|------------------|-------------------|
| Behavior Description | [Specific actions during the accident] |
| Whether Violation Exists | [Yes/No, specify] |
| Violated Provisions | [List specific articles] |
| Fault Severity Assessment | [High/Medium/Low, explain rationale] |
### Party B ([Party B description])
[Same format as above]
*[If more parties exist, list them sequentially]*
## 4. Photo Analysis Results (If available)
### Key Findings
1. **[Finding 1]**:[Detailed description and its significance for determination]
2. **[Finding 2]**:[Detailed description and its significance for determination]
...
### Scene Reconstruction
[Text description or ASCII diagram]
## 5. Liability Determination Conclusion
### Comprehensive Determination
| Party | Liability Level | Liability Proportion | Basis Summary |
|------|----------------|---------------------|--------------|
| Party A | [Level] | [XX%] | [Core reason] |
| Party B | [Level] | [XX%] | [Core reason] |
### Determination Reasoning Process
1. **Step One - Violation Identification**:
- Party A: [List]
- Party B: [List]
2. **Step Two - Causal Relationship Analysis**:
- [Analyze the strength of the causal link between each violation and the accident]
3. **Step Three - Fault Comparison**:
- [Compare the severity of each party's faults]
4. **Step Four - Comprehensive Assessment**:
- [Complete logical chain leading to the final liability division]
## 6. Detailed Legal Basis
### Substantive Law Basis
**1. Road Traffic Safety Law of the People's Republic of China**
- **Article XX** [Article Title]:
> [Original citation]
> *Application note: [Explain how this article applies to the case]*
- **Article XX** [Article Title]:
> [Original citation]
> *Application note: [Explain how this article applies to the case]*
**2. Regulation on the Implementation of the Road Traffic Safety Law of the People's Republic of China**
- **Article XX** [Article Title]:
> [Original citation]
### Procedural Law Basis (If applicable)
**3. Procedures for Handling Road Traffic Accidents**
- **Article XX** [Article Title]:
> [Original citation]
## 7. Legal Advice
### Advice for Party A
1. [Advice 1]
2. [Advice 2]
### Advice for Party B
1. [Advice 1]
2. [Advice 2]
### Follow-up Procedure Suggestions
1. [Procedure suggestion]
2. [Procedure suggestion]
## 8. Disclaimer
> ⚠️ **Important Note**: This assessment report is generated by an AI system based on user-provided information and is for reference only.
>
> - This report cannot replace an official Road Traffic Accident Determination issued by the public security traffic management department
> - The final liability determination shall be based on the official investigation conclusion of the traffic police department
> - If personal injury or significant property damage is involved, it is recommended to retain a professional lawyer promptly
> - The legal provisions cited in this report are publicly available regulatory content, but specific application requires consideration of all case facts
>
> Generation time: [Timestamp]
---
*End of Report*
Special Scenario Handling Guide
Scenario One: Rear-End Collision
Typical Features: Rear vehicle hits the front vehicle's rear
Determination Key Points:
- Generally, the rear vehicle bears primary or full liability (Law Article 43: Safe distance)
- Front vehicle behavior must be reviewed for sudden braking, illegal parking, etc.
- Multi-vehicle chain rear-end collisions require segment-by-segment analysis
Special Exemption Circumstances:
- Front vehicle suddenly and illegally changes lanes, leaving rear vehicle no time to avoid
- Front vehicle brake light is malfunctioning and fails to show braking signal
- Front vehicle illegally parks or reverses on the highway
Scenario Two: Intersection Collision
Typical Features: Two vehicles conflict at an intersection
Determination Key Points:
- First confirm signal light status (signal color for each party)
- When no signal light is present, determine based on yield rules (Law Article 52)
- Application of the right-side vehicle priority principle
- Priority of vehicles already inside the intersection
Priority Order (High to Low):
- Traffic signal lights
- Traffic police direction
- Traffic signs and markings
- Yield rules (slow down and yield, stop and yield)
- Right-side priority principle
Scenario Three: Lane Change/Merge Accident
Typical Features: Collision when changing lanes
Determination Key Points:
- The lane-changing party usually bears primary liability (Law Article 45)
- Review whether the lane change timing was safe and whether turn signals were activated in advance
- Assess whether the party being merged into engaged in improper behavior like accelerating to block
- "Right of way" concept: Vehicles driving normally in their lane have priority
Scenario Four: Motor Vehicle vs Pedestrian Accident
Typical Features: Motor vehicle collides with pedestrian
Determination Key Points:
- Motor vehicles bear higher duty of care (Law Article 47)
- Check whether the pedestrian violated traffic signals, jumped over barriers, etc.
- Motor vehicles must yield in crosswalk areas (Law Article 47, Paragraph 1)
- Even if the pedestrian is at fault, the motor vehicle usually still bears some liability
Liability Reduction Conditions (Law Article 76):
- If the pedestrian intentionally causes the accident, the motor vehicle bears no liability
- If the pedestrian is grossly negligent, the motor vehicle's liability may be reduced
Scenario Five: Motor Vehicle vs Non-Motor Vehicle Accident
Typical Features: Motor vehicle collides with bicycle/electric bike, etc.
Determination Key Points:
- Whether the non-motor vehicle is traveling within the non-motor vehicle lane
- Whether the non-motor vehicle is carrying passengers, going against traffic, running red lights, etc.
- Motor vehicles on mixed roads must exercise a higher duty of care
- Electric bikes must be distinguished based on whether they meet the new national standard (whether classified as motor vehicle)
Scenario Six: Drunk/Intoxicated Driving Accidents
Determination Key Points:
- Drunk driving itself is a serious violation (Law Article 22, Paragraph 2)
- A causal relationship must be established between drunk driving and the accident
- Intoxicated driving also violates Criminal Law Article 133-1 (Dangerous Driving)
- Even if the other party is also at fault, the drunk driving party's liability is usually not waived
Core Legal Provisions Index
The following are the most frequently used core provisions. For full details, refer to references/traffic-laws.md:
Core Provisions of the Road Traffic Safety Law
| Article | Core Content | Relevance to Determination |
|---|---|---|
| Article 8 | Vehicle registration system | ★★☆ |
| Article 19 | Driver's license management | ★★★ |
| Article 22 | Safe driving duty | ★★★ |
| Article 35 | Prohibition of driving against traffic | ★★★ |
| Article 38 | Traffic signal passage | ★★★ |
| Article 42 | Speed limit regulations | ★★★ |
| Article 43 | Safe distance/overtaking rules | ★★★ |
| Article 44 | Driving in separate lanes | ★★★ |
| Article 45 | Lane changing | ★★★ |
| Article 47 | Duty to yield | ★★★ |
| Article 51 | Seat belts/helmets | ★★☆ |
| Article 56 | Parking regulations | ★★☆ |
| Article 61 | Pedestrian passage rules | ★★★ |
| Article 62 | Pedestrian prohibited acts | ★★★ |
| Article 70 | Accident scene handling | ★★☆ |
| Article 73 | Traffic accident determination | ★★★ |
| Article 76 | Motor vehicle exemption/liability reduction | ★★★ |
Guardrails
Principles That Must Be Followed
- Legal Basis Authenticity: All cited legal provisions must be existing and currently effective regulations; do not fabricate or alter legal text
- Liability Determination Prudence: For complex or borderline cases, provide multiple possible analyses rather than arbitrary conclusions
- Information Completeness Statement: When user-provided information is insufficient for accurate judgment, explicitly point out information gaps
- Disclaimer Must Not Be Omitted: Each output assessment report must include a complete disclaimer section
- Do Not Replace Law Enforcement: Always emphasize that this assessment is for reference only; final determination authority lies with the traffic police
Prohibited Actions
- Do not provide definitive predictions like "you will definitely win/lose"
- Do not fabricate legal provisions or judicial interpretations that do not exist
- Do not ignore obvious violations without analysis
- Do not force a specific liability proportion number without sufficient information
- Do not provide specific compensation amount calculations (due to large regional standard variations)
Uncertainty Handling
When encountering the following situations, mark "Uncertain" in the report and explain the reason:
- Contradictory accident details
- Controversial space in legal application
- Differences between local regulations and higher-level laws
- Lack of key evidence (e.g., no surveillance, no witnesses)
- Legal qualification of new types of vehicles (e.g., shared bikes, electric scooters)
Reference Loading Guide
For in-depth analysis scenarios, load the following references as needed:
references/traffic-laws.md: Contains key excerpts and interpretations of the full Road Traffic Safety Lawreferences/liability-rules.md: Contains detailed liability determination rule matrix and typical case comparisonsreferences/accident-types.md: Contains standardized analysis processes for various common accident types
Loading Strategy:
- Simple inquiry → Use only built-in knowledge from SKILL.md
- Complex case analysis → Load
liability-rules.mdfor auxiliary determination - Need precise legal citation → Load
traffic-laws.mdfor complete provisions - Special accident types → Load
accident-types.mdfor specialized analysis guide