Communitygithub.com

bangwozuo/launch-commander-en

Sentiment analysis for launch-day comments on ProductHunt. Five-category labels (positive/negative/neutral/question/risk) + six risk subtypes (vote manipulation, privacy concerns, refund requests, plagiarism allegations, viability doubts, paid reviews), prioritized P0-P4 with response SLAs (30 min for PH first-day comments). Comes with a Python script to generate Excel classification reports and a sentiment distribution PNG. Use when you need launch-day comment monitoring, classification, negative comment alerts, or comment priority queuing.

What is launch-commander-en?

This skill, 'launch-commander', provides automated sentiment analysis and risk detection for launch-day comments, particularly on ProductHunt. It classifies each comment into one of five sentiment categories (positive, negative, neutral, question, risk) and detects six specific risk subtypes: vote manipulation accusations, security/privacy concerns, refund requests, plagiarism/competitor claims, product viability doubts, and paid review allegations. Based on these classifications, it builds a priority queue from P0 (highest – 30-minute SLA) to P4 (lowest – 48-hour SLA), ensuring that critical negative comments or risks are surfaced to the developer immediately. The skill includes a Python script (`emotion_scan.py`) that produces an Excel spreadsheet with the full classified list and a pie chart PNG for sentiment distribution. It is designed for use in workflows like daily comment duty (every 15 minutes) and launch-day battle review (T+1). The skill explicitly does not write reply drafts, auto-reply, or delete any comments; it only flags and prioritizes. It requires no API keys and runs entirely on a semantic wordlist and rules engine, with a fallback to an AI model (e.g., Claude) for nuanced tasks like sarcasm detection and fake account review.

Works with~Claude Code~Codex CLI~Cursor
npx skills add https://github.com/bangwozuo/launch-commander-zh/tree/HEAD/skills/comment-emotion-detect

Ask in your favorite AI

Open a new chat with this agent skill pre-loaded.

Documentation

Comment Sentiment Analysis

Cut the launch-day comment stream into four tiers: "Must reply immediately" / "Must reply carefully" / "Record" / "No need to reply." P0 risks must be escalated to the developer within 30 minutes. On ProductHunt, first-day comment response speed directly affects ranking – slow recognition = ranking loss.

What this skill does not do: write reply content (that's for reply-drafting), execute auto-replies, or delete any comments.

Meta Information

FieldValue
IDde_dev_02_sk07
Typeatomic
EmployeeLaunch Commander
Capability FamilyDetection & Judgment · Sentiment Classification & Risk Alert
ComplexityM
StageP1
ReusabilityMedium (T+1 postmortem reuses comment data)
Asset FormDeep prompt + Python script (no model calls, no API key)

Capability Description

  1. Five Sentiment Labels: 🟢 Positive / ⚠️ Negative / ⚪ Neutral / 🔵 Question / 🔴 Risk, with negation flip and "feature request ≠ positive review" correction
  2. Six Risk Subtypes: Vote manipulation accusations, security/privacy concerns, refund requests, plagiarism/competitor claims, product viability doubts, paid review allegations – each with standard handling actions and SLA
  3. Priority Queue: P0 Risk (30 minutes) → P1 Negative (PH first-day 30 minutes) → P2 Question (2 hours) → P3 Positive (24 hours) → P4 Neutral (48 hours)
  4. Health Baseline: Positive ratio ≥ 60% and risk = 0 is healthy; negative > 20% triggers pinned clarification and coordinated response; questions > 30% indicates gaps in launch materials

Input Specification

FieldTypeRequiredDescription
commentsarray✅Comment stream, each with text (try to include full text) + user + platform
platformstring⬜Main platform: ProductHunt / Reddit / V2EX / X / Jike / Weibo / WeChat Official / Generic
productstring⬜Product name, used for context

Output Specification

  • summary: Five-class count, positive ratio, P0/P1 count, health line determination
  • queue: Priority queue (P0→P4), each item with risk subtype / SLA / suggested action / pending manual confirmation status

Artifacts:

FileContent
out/comment_classification_list.xlsxPriority queue (risk rows highlighted red) / classification details / summary
out/sentiment_distribution.pngPie chart of five sentiment categories
out/emotion_scan.jsonMachine-readable results, for workflow (daily-comment-duty-flow) consumption

Usage Steps

Method 1: Pure Prompt (Fastest, Includes Context Judgment)

  1. Paste the entire contents of prompt.txt as the system prompt
  2. Provide the comment stream (full text, with platform labels)
  3. Receive sentiment overview + priority queue + items requiring model review (sarcasm, fake accounts)

Method 2: With Script (Precise Word Scoring + Excel/PNG Output)

python3 <SKILL_DIR>/scripts/emotion_scan.py --input input.json --outdir out
python3 <SKILL_DIR>/scripts/emotion_scan.py --demo        # Works even without input

Division of Labor: The script handles wordlist scoring, negation flips, risk rule scanning, and P0-P4 queuing (complete, no guessing); the model handles sarcasm detection, fake account review, and veteran user negative comment attribution (things the script cannot do). The two results are cross-checked.

Boundaries (What This Skill Does Not Do)

  • ❌ Does not delete comments or recommend deletion – "Acknowledge + offer solution" is the only correct posture for negative comments
  • ❌ Does not write reply content (that's reply-drafting's job), only provides handling direction
  • ❌ Does not count feature requests as positive reviews (would inflate sentiment and misjudge PMF)
  • ❌ No automated context judgment – sarcasm and fake accounts must be reviewed by the model
  • ❌ If the comment stream is empty, outputs "Launch day 0 comments" and prompts to check the launch link – does not fabricate data

Example Call

Input (examples/input.json, excerpt):

{
  "product": "ClipMate (Clipboard History Tool)",
  "comments": [
    {"user": "maker_fan99", "platform": "ProductHunt", "text": "Congrats! Finally a clipboard manager that doesn't feel bloated. Love the search speed."},
    {"user": "angry_bob", "platform": "ProductHunt", "text": "Crashed twice within 10 minutes. How do I get a refund?"},
    {"user": "privacy_nut", "platform": "V2EX", "text": "Will clipboard data be uploaded to the server?"}
  ]
}

Output (script run, exit code 0): Positive 1 / Negative 0 / Neutral 2 / Question 1 / Risk 3, P0+P1 total 3 items – angry_bob "refund" hits refund request P0; "doesn't feel bloated" is correctly identified as a positive review after negation flip. See examples/output.md for details.

Workflows

  • daily-comment-duty-flow (daily comment duty, every 15 minutes)
  • launch-battle-review-flow (launch postmortem review, T+1)

Compliance Statement

  • Outputs are labeled "AI-generated content"; all actions require "pending manual confirmation" before execution
  • Comment content is user data: the classification list is limited to launch duty use only; not shared externally, not publicly screenshot (positive quote citations require permission)
  • No auto-replies; all reply drafts must go through reply-drafting and receive manual confirmation

This skill follows the bangwozuo Digital Employee Asset Specification v3.0

Related Skills