Communitygithub.com

/design-critique - 设计评论

从可用性、信息层级和一致性等多个维度获得结构化设计反馈。通过“review this design”、“critique this mockup”、“what do you think of this screen?”或分享 Figma 链接、截图来触发,适用于从探索到最终打磨的任何阶段。

design-critique - 设计评论 是什么?

此技能为设计师、产品经理及任何需要设计反馈的人提供一套系统化的结构化评论框架。你可以通过提供 Figma 链接、上传截图或详细描述来提交设计。技能基于一个多维度评价模型,涵盖第一印象、可用性、视觉层级、一致性及可访问性,并按照指定格式输出包含优先建议的详细报告。该工具支持在 Figma 连接可用时直接拉取设计并检查组件与样式令牌,也支持关联用户反馈数据以验证设计决策。它鼓励用户提供上下文(如目标用户、设计阶段)和关注点(如“聚焦移动端”),从而获得更具针对性的反馈。最终输出的评论清晰、可操作,并包含严重性评级与改进建议,既适用于早期探索,也适用于最终打磨阶段。

兼容平台~Claude Code~Codex CLI~Cursor
npx skills add https://github.com/tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch/tree/HEAD/.agents/plugins/anthropic-design/skills/design-critique

在你喜欢的 AI 中提问

打开一个已预加载此 Agent Skill 的新对话。

文档

/design-critique

如果你看到不熟悉的占位符,或需要检查哪些工具已连接,请参阅 CONNECTORS.md。

从多个维度获得结构化设计反馈。

使用方法

/design-critique $ARGUMENTS

审查设计:@$1

如果提供了 Figma URL,则从 Figma 拉取设计。如果引用了文件,则读取该文件。否则,请用户描述或分享他们的设计。

我需要你提供的信息

  • 设计:Figma URL、截图或详细描述
  • 背景:这是什么?目标用户是谁?处于哪个阶段(探索、细化、最终)?
  • 关注点(可选):“聚焦移动端”或“聚焦新手引导流程”

评论框架

1. 第一印象(2秒)

  • 眼睛首先被什么吸引?这正确吗?
  • 情感反应是什么?
  • 目的是否立即清晰?

2. 可用性

  • 用户能否完成他们的目标?
  • 导航是否直观?
  • 交互元素是否明显?
  • 是否存在不必要的步骤?

3. 视觉层级

  • 是否有清晰的阅读顺序?
  • 正确的元素是否被强调?
  • 空白区域的使用是否有效?
  • 排版是否创建了正确的层级?

4. 一致性

  • 是否遵循设计系统?
  • 间距、颜色和排版是否一致?
  • 相似的元素是否行为相似?

5. 可访问性

  • 颜色对比度
  • 触摸目标大小
  • 文本可读性
  • 图片替代文本

如何给出反馈

  • 具体说明:“CTA 与导航形成竞争”,而不是“布局让人困惑”
  • 解释原因:将反馈与设计原则或用户需求联系起来
  • 提出替代方案:不只是指出问题,还要提出解决方案
  • 认可有效之处:好的反馈包括正面观察
  • 匹配阶段:早期探索的反馈不同于最终打磨的反馈

输出

## 设计评论:[设计名称]

### 总体印象
[1-2 句第一反应——哪些做得好,最大的机会点是什么]

### 可用性
| 发现 | 严重程度 | 建议 |
|------|----------|------|
| [问题] | 🔴 严重 / 🟡 中等 / 🟢 轻微 | [修复] |

### 视觉层级
- **首先吸引视线**:[元素] — [这正确吗?]
- **阅读流程**:[视线如何在布局中移动?]
- **强调**:[正确的元素是否被强调?]

### 一致性
| 元素 | 问题 | 建议 |
|------|------|------|
| [排版/间距/颜色] | [不一致] | [修复] |

### 可访问性
- **颜色对比度**:[关键文本通过/未通过]
- **触摸目标**:[尺寸是否足够?]
- **文本可读性**:[字体大小、行高]

### 哪些做得好
- [正面观察 1]
- [正面观察 2]

### 优先建议
1. **[影响最大的更改]** — [原因和方式]
2. **[次要优先]** — [原因和方式]
3. **[第三优先]** — [原因和方式]

如果连接器可用

如果 ~~设计工具 已连接:

  • 直接从 Figma 拉取设计,并检查组件、令牌和图层
  • 与现有设计系统进行一致性对比

如果 ~~用户反馈 已连接:

  • 将设计决策与最近的用户反馈和支持工单进行交叉验证

提示

  1. 分享背景 ——“这是一个面向 B2B SaaS 的结账流程”有助于我给出相关反馈。
  2. 说明你的阶段 —— 早期探索的反馈不同于最终打磨的反馈。
  3. 要求我聚焦 —— “只看导航”能让你在某一区域获得更深入的反馈。

Individual skills in this repo

This repo contains 15 individual skills — each has its own dedicated page.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Run a WCAG 2.1 AA accessibility audit on a design or page. Trigger with "audit accessibility", "check a11y", "is this accessible?", or when reviewing a design for color contrast, keyboard navigation, touch target size, or screen reader behavior before handoff.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Generate developer handoff specs from a design. Use when a design is ready for engineering and needs a spec sheet covering layout, design tokens, component props, interaction states, responsive breakpoints, edge cases, and animation details.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Audit, document, or extend your design system. Use when checking for naming inconsistencies or hardcoded values across components, writing documentation for a component's variants, states, and accessibility notes, or designing a new pattern that fits the existing system.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Synthesize user research into themes, insights, and recommendations. Use when you have interview transcripts, survey results, usability test notes, support tickets, or NPS responses that need to be distilled into patterns, user segments, and prioritized next steps.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Plan, conduct, and synthesize user research. Trigger with "user research plan", "interview guide", "usability test", "survey design", "research questions", or when the user needs help with any aspect of understanding their users through research.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Write or review UX copy — microcopy, error messages, empty states, CTAs. Trigger with "write copy for", "what should this button say?", "review this error message", or when naming a CTA, wording a confirmation dialog, filling an empty state, or writing onboarding text.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Design banners for social media, ads, website heroes, creative assets, and print. Multiple art direction options with AI-generated visuals. Actions: design, create, generate banner. Platforms: Facebook, Twitter/X, LinkedIn, YouTube, Instagram, Google Display, website hero, print. Styles: minimalist, gradient, bold typography, photo-based, illustrated, geometric, retro, glassmorphism, 3D, neon, duotone, editorial, collage. Uses ui-ux-pro-max, frontend-design, ai-artist, ai-multimodal skills.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Brand voice, visual identity, messaging frameworks, asset management, brand consistency. Activate for branded content, tone of voice, marketing assets, brand compliance, style guides.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Comprehensive design skill: brand identity, design tokens, UI styling, logo generation (55 styles, Gemini AI), corporate identity program (50 deliverables, CIP mockups), HTML presentations (Chart.js), banner design (22 styles, social/ads/web/print), icon design (15 styles, SVG, Gemini 3.1 Pro), social photos (HTML→screenshot, multi-platform). Actions: design logo, create CIP, generate mockups, build slides, design banner, generate icon, create social photos, social media images, brand identity, design system. Platforms: Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, YouTube, Instagram, Pinterest, TikTok, Threads, Google Ads.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Audit, document, or extend your design system. Use when checking for naming inconsistencies or hardcoded values across components, writing documentation for a component's variants, states, and accessibility notes, or designing a new pattern that fits the existing system.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Translates Figma designs into production-ready application code with 1:1 visual fidelity. Use when implementing UI code from Figma files, when user mentions "implement design", "generate code", "implement component", provides Figma URLs, or asks to build components matching Figma specs. For Figma canvas writes via `use_figma`, use `figma-use`.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Use the Figma MCP server to fetch design context, screenshots, variables, and assets from Figma, and to translate Figma nodes into production code. Trigger when a task involves Figma URLs, node IDs, design-to-code implementation, or Figma MCP setup and troubleshooting.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Create strategic HTML presentations with Chart.js, design tokens, responsive layouts, copywriting formulas, and contextual slide strategies.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

Create beautiful, accessible user interfaces with shadcn/ui components (built on Radix UI + Tailwind), Tailwind CSS utility-first styling, and canvas-based visual designs. Use when building user interfaces, implementing design systems, creating responsive layouts, adding accessible components (dialogs, dropdowns, forms, tables), customizing themes and colors, implementing dark mode, generating visual designs and posters, or establishing consistent styling patterns across applications.

tmnhutwork/Landingpage-Photo-Retouch

UI/UX design intelligence for web, mobile, and desktop. This skill should be used when designing, building, reviewing, or fixing interfaces, including pages, components, design systems, accessibility, interaction, responsive layout, typography, color, charts, and stack-specific UI implementation. Searchable local data: 79 searchable styles (50 active), 192 product palettes and reasoning profiles, 74 font pairings, 119 UX guidelines, 105 icons, 17 GSAP presets, 25 chart types, and 22 stacks.

相关技能