Hook check
The opening line is where most people decide to keep watching or swipe. This skill grades a hook against the five hook criteria and two checks of the open short-form script benchmark (https://github.com/viewgum/short-form-script-benchmark), then rewrites it. It is one grader's reading of a fixed rubric, not the benchmark's averaged and cross-checked score, and it does not predict views or retention.
A hook here is three parts: the spoken first line, the text on screen during it, and what the viewer sees. Many people watch on mute, so the on-screen text has to work alone.
Not for: a whole script (use short-form-script), or titles and captions (use post-copy).
Workflow
- Get the hook and, if you can, the topic and the audience. If the user gives only a spoken line, grade it and say the on-screen text is missing (H5 and D4h score 0).
- Run the two checks by counting, not judging:
- D2 Fast start: 0 if the line opens with a greeting or filler ("hey", "hi", "hello", "welcome", "so", "today", "okay", "ok", "alright", "guys", "in this video"); otherwise 2 if the first sentence has 15 words or fewer, 1 if 20 or fewer, else 0.
- D4h Hook text: 2 if the on-screen text has 1 to 7 words, 1 if 8 to 10, else 0.
- Score H1 to H5, each 0, 1 or 2, against the anchors below. Quote the words that earn each 1 or 2. If nothing earns it, give 0.
- Write three new hooks, each with spoken line, on-screen text (7 words or fewer) and visual. Each should lift the lowest scores and keep the topic and its facts. Never add a statistic, quote or claim the user did not give.
- Score your three the same way and show the scores. If one scores lower than the original on any criterion, say so.
Criteria
| Id | Criterion | 0 | 1 | 2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| H1 | Topic clarity in the first line | the topic is unclear after the first sentence | the topic is named but vague | a concrete topic and outcome, with one reading |
| H2 | Curiosity or stakes | a plain statement with no gap | a generic tease or a stock "the truth is" contrast | a specific contrast or concrete stakes the viewer wants resolved |
| H3 | Relevance to the audience | about the speaker, no stakes for the viewer | the viewer is implied | speaks to the stated audience with an outcome they need |
| H4 | Promise of what is coming | no signal of what the end holds | an implied ending | a visible promise or mechanism in the first five seconds |
| H5 | Hook on mute | no on-screen hook text, or text that makes no sense without sound | on-screen text that is long, busy or gives the answer away | 7 words or fewer that make sense on mute and hold back the answer |
Hook score out of 100 = 100 x (0.8 x (H1 to H5 total / 10) + 0.2 x ((D2 + D4h) / 4)), which with whole grades is 8 x (H1 + H2 + H3 + H4 + H5) + 5 x (D2 + D4h).
Output format
**Hook score:** 58 / 100
**Weakest:** D2 (opens with a greeting), H2 (no gap)
| Criterion | Score | Quote | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| H1 Topic clarity | 1 | "..." | ... |
| H2 Curiosity or stakes | 1 | "..." | ... |
| H3 Relevance to the audience | 1 | "..." | ... |
| H4 Promise of what is coming | 1 | "..." | ... |
| H5 Hook on mute | 2 | "..." | ... |
| D2 Fast start | 0 | opens with "Hey" | |
| D4h Hook text | 2 | 6 words | |
### Rewrites
1. **Say:** ... **On screen:** ... **Visual:** ... (score 84: H1 2, H2 2, H3 1, H4 2, H5 1; D2 2, D4h 2; lower than the original on H5,
1 against 2)
2. ...
3. ...
- Plain language, one short reason per row (under 15 words).
- Quotes are the user's exact words.
- Keep the user's facts; flag any line that states a figure the user did not give.
Common pitfalls
- Do not reward length or polish: a short plain line can score 2 on every criterion.
- Do not count a question alone as curiosity. "Want to save money?" is a plain statement with a question mark (H2 0 or 1).
- Do not put the answer in the on-screen text; it removes the reason to keep watching (H5 1 at most).
- Do not invent numbers to raise the stakes. A rewrite with a made-up statistic is worse than the original.
- Do not grade the visual on taste. It counts only through H4 (does it show the mechanism) and H5 (does the text read on mute).