Ad To Page Promise Match
Use this skill when
A paid click lands on a page that may say something different from the ad. This skill builds a promise list from the ad and checks each promise against the first screen and CTA. Every mismatch is a hypothesis for a test. None proves a cause.
Common requests:
- "Ads get clicks but nobody signs up."
- "Check message match on our trial campaign."
- "Does the page match the ad?"
- "High CTR, low signup rate on Meta. Is it the page?"
Send these jobs to another skill:
- Whole-page value review with no ad to compare:
landing-page-value-review-saas-ads. - Field count or form steps:
signup-form-friction-review-saas-ads. - Plan and price layout:
pricing-page-review-saas-ads. - Signups that do not become paying customers:
trial-to-paid-by-campaign-saas-ads. - Signups missing from reports:
signup-event-audit-saas-ads.
Required input
Work from pasted exports and screenshots. No live account access is needed. If an input is missing, stop that finding, name the missing input, return needs_data, and do not estimate. A count below a volume floor returns needs_data (T01).
Required
- Exact ad text. Google Ads: every headline and description. Meta: primary text, headline, description, and text on the creative.
- Targeting. Google Ads: the ad group keywords. Meta: the audience definition and the ad's angle.
- Final URL for each ad.
- Full-page screenshots of that URL on desktop and mobile, dated.
- Page text exactly as copied from the live page.
- Offer terms: trial length, price, and whether a card is needed.
Optional
- Ad-level clicks and signups for the same dates.
- Campaign paid rates for the T03 check.
- Dated page releases and ad edits.
Export route:
- Google Ads: open Ads, filter to the campaign, and download headlines, descriptions, and final URL.
- Google Ads: open Keywords for the same ad groups and download.
- Meta: in Ads Manager, export ad-level text and destination URL, then copy each ad set's audience.
- Open each final URL in a clean browser window and capture desktop and mobile.
See ../saas-ads-shared/references/getting-your-data.md.
Analysis workflow
Read ../saas-ads-shared/references/thresholds.md before step 1.
- List each ad with its final URL. Group ads that share a URL.
- Build a promise list per ad: audience, offer, price or trial terms, key words, and proof. Quote the ad exactly.
- Add targeting context: keyword theme for Google Ads, audience and angle for Meta.
- Mark the first screen on each device as the content visible before scrolling. Record headline, subhead, CTA label, terms, and proof shown there.
- Check each promise against the first screen and CTA. Mark it
match,changed, orabsent, quoting page text as supplied. - Flag different offer wording, a missing keyword theme, differing trial terms, a different audience, a different CTA verb, and ad proof absent from the page.
- Rank mismatches by notice order. Within a rank, list the ad with more clicks first when click data exists.
- When paid rates are supplied, check T03 and note any trial or price mismatch on a flagged campaign.
- Write each mismatch as a test: page or ad change, measure to watch, and owner.
Decision rules
Thresholds live in ../saas-ads-shared/references/thresholds.md. Labels and tags follow ../saas-ads-shared/references/output-standard.md.
Notice order, a working rule of this skill:
| Rank | Mismatch type | Severity |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Trial length, card, or price differs | high |
| 2 | Offer differs (trial versus demo) | high |
| 3 | Audience differs | medium |
| 4 | Keyword theme or angle missing | medium |
| 5 | CTA verb differs | medium |
| 6 | Ad proof absent from page | low |
| Pattern | Verdict | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Both quotes supplied and they contradict | confirmed mismatch, effect possible | Test, approval_needed |
| Promise sits below the fold on one device | likely mismatch on that device | Test moving it up |
| Screenshot, page text, or ad export missing | needs_data | Request it |
| T03 flag plus differing trial or price terms | possible link | trial-to-paid-by-campaign-saas-ads |
| Page price differs from ad price | confirmed mismatch | pricing-page-review-saas-ads |
| All promises match, signups still low | monitor | landing-page-value-review-saas-ads |
Output format
## Promise match: [campaign], [platform], [capture date]
Final URL: [url] | Targeting: [keyword theme or audience and angle] | Terms: [trial, price, card]
### Promise list
| Ad | Promise type | Ad text (exact) | First screen text (exact) | Device | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
### Decision table
| Finding | Evidence | Verdict | Severity | Confidence | Business impact | Next step |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
### Ranked test hypotheses
[mismatch, change to test, measure to watch, approval owner]
### Data gaps
[missing input and the finding it would firm up]
Practical example
Illustrative only: made-up ad and page text for a fictional invoicing tool.
Google Ads keyword theme: "invoice software". Headlines: "Invoice Software For Freelancers", "Free 14-Day Trial, No Card", "Award-Winning Invoicing". Description CTA: "Start your free trial."
Desktop and mobile first screen: headline "Invoice Software For Finance Teams", subhead "7-day trial. Card required.", button "Start free trial". Page text mentions no award.
| Finding | Evidence | Verdict | Severity | Confidence | Business impact | Next step |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trial is 7 days shorter, card required | ads_export, screenshot, page_text | confirmed mismatch | high | high | signups | Owner decides which terms are correct, approval_needed |
| Audience shifts to finance teams | ads_export, page_text | confirmed mismatch | medium | high | signups | Test a freelancer headline |
| Award claim absent | ads_export, page_text | confirmed mismatch | low | medium | client_trust | Verify claim or remove it |
Keyword theme and CTA verb match. Effect on signups stays possible until a test reads out.
Common failure modes
- Paraphrasing ad or page text instead of quoting it.
- Reviewing the whole page when the visitor decides on the first screen.
- Skipping the mobile capture.
- Calling a mismatch the cause of low signups.
- Comparing an ad with a page released after the ad's dates.
- Reading high CTR as proof the page is wrong.
Route to next
Page value and proof: landing-page-value-review-saas-ads. Form steps: signup-form-friction-review-saas-ads. Paid rate by campaign: trial-to-paid-by-campaign-saas-ads. Price and plans: pricing-page-review-saas-ads.
Guardrails
- Never change a live account, budget, bid, tag, page, price, or form.
- Never invent numbers, quotes, claims, or results.
- End in an approval-ready recommendation for a named owner.
- Quote ad and page text exactly as supplied.
- Never present a mismatch as a proven cause of low signups.
- Never choose trial, card, or price terms. Flag the gap and route the decision.
- Never judge an ad against a capture from a different date without a
change_lognote. - Never request or echo names, emails, or phone numbers. Ask for them removed before per-customer rows are pasted.
- If the account is ecommerce or lead-gen rather than SaaS, say so and stop.