Visually Balanced
The eye perceives mass (area × darkness × complexity), not bounding boxes. Geometrically equal is not visually equal. Build with math and a grid first, then correct optically. Math is the starting point; the eye is the final judge.
Use this skill when:
- Creating icons, logos, app icons, illustrations, SVG/CSS shapes
- Building buttons, chips, badges, nav bars, cards, icon + text combos
- Composing layouts with several shapes or elements side by side
- Reviewing a design (screenshot, Figma export, HTML) where something "feels off"
Core rules (with starting values)
1. Equalize mass, not the bounding box
- Shapes in the same box look different sizes: the square looks biggest, the circle smaller, the triangle smallest.
- Equal-area circle diameter ≈ 1.13 × square side. In practice use ~1.08–1.12× (Material keylines: 18px square ↔ 20px circle on a 24px grid).
- Triangles and pointed shapes: enlarge ~1.15–1.25× relative to a square.
- Continuous blocks (pills, rectangles) weigh more than separated shapes with gaps or pinch points. A pill next to two stacked circles of the same width carries ~13% more area; narrowing the pill ~8% (100 → 92) brings it close to equal.
- When unsure, compute the real filled area of each element and make them roughly equal.
2. Overshoot
- Round and pointed shapes must extend slightly past the baseline, cap line or container edge, otherwise they look smaller.
- Overshoot ≈ 1.5–3% of the height (in type, "O" is taller than "H" and the apex of "A" rises past cap height).
3. Optical centering
- Asymmetric shapes: a right-pointing triangle's centroid sits w/6 (≈17% of its width) left of its box center. Shift it right somewhere between 0 and w/6; most play icons land at ~8–15% of the triangle's width.
- Vertical: the true center reads as low. Place content ~2–5% above the geometric center (posters, empty states, modals, hero blocks).
- Directional icons (arrows, chevrons): nudge slightly toward the direction they point.
4. The top half looks bigger
- Make the upper part of stacked forms slightly smaller ("S", "8", "B", stacked layouts).
5. Horizontal strokes look thicker
- Make horizontal strokes ~5–10% thinner than vertical ones for equal perceived weight.
6. Color and value carry weight
- Dark, saturated, warm = heavy. Light, desaturated, cool = light.
- A lighter element can be slightly larger to balance a darker one; or lighten the heavier side. Shape and color corrections can be combined.
7. Complexity and isolation add weight
- Detailed or textured elements outweigh plain ones of the same size.
- An element alone in whitespace draws more attention than one inside a group.
8. Buttons and icon + text
- Icon side padding: reduce by ~2–4px (or ~0.75×) compared with the text side.
- Text vertical centering: lowercase-heavy labels often need a ~1px upward nudge; all-caps labels usually center cleanly.
- Icons inside circular buttons: apply rule 3 to asymmetric glyphs.
Workflow
- Build with math: grid, equal values, consistent spacing.
- Measure mass: compare filled areas and visual weight, not widths.
- Correct optically: apply the rules above; keep corrections small (usually 1–10%).
- Verify:
- Squint test or blur: which side leaves the darker, bigger blob?
- Flip or mirror: imbalance becomes obvious once the eye loses familiarity.
- For code-generated visuals, render and measure with the script below.
- Report the adjustments with exact values (e.g. "pill width 100 → 92, play icon +6px right").
Measuring (scripts/measure_balance.py)
Treats darkness as weight and reports the visual centroid and mass ratios. Accepts PNG/JPG, or SVG if cairosvg is installed.
python scripts/measure_balance.py design.png
python scripts/measure_balance.py icon.svg --blur blur.png # also save a squint-test image
python scripts/measure_balance.py layout.png --split 112 # compare two groups split at x=112px
python scripts/measure_balance.py layout.png --json
- Use
--split(fraction or px) to compare two groups that meet somewhere other than the midline. - Targets: left/right ratio ~0.95–1.05 for compositions meant to look symmetric; centroid x near 0; centroid y slightly negative (above center) is fine.
- For a single asymmetric shape, trust the centroid, not the midline ratio.
- Numbers guide, eyes decide: always look at the blurred image too.
Review output format
When reviewing a design, list each issue as:
- Element: what feels off, why (which rule), fix with a concrete value.
Keep it short and skip elements that already look balanced.