Screening Room
A review panel that costs what the decision is worth. Ninety-two lenses are a library to cast from. A run reads what kind of work it has been given, seats the handful of lenses that belong in that register, has each craft propose exact changes, debates only where crafts collide, and ends with one final version that a skeptic has tried to break.
What a lens is
A lens is an archetype: one way of looking at the work, with a stance, the things it pushes back on and the questions it asks. It is a tool for looking. It is not a person, it carries no name, and it speaks for nobody.
- Refer to a lens by its title: "The Still Tableau asks whether…".
- Never attribute a lens's view to a real person, and never write that any real person said, wants or approves something.
- A lens gives questions, not authority. A proposal stands on its reason, not on which lens raised it.
Depth
Pick the smallest depth that fits the stakes. Ask only if the user has given no signal.
| Depth | Crafts | Lenses per craft | Disputes | Use for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
quick | 3 | 2 | settled inline by the chair | a check before a cheap, repeatable step |
standard (default) | 4 to 5 | 2 to 3 | up to 6, debated | most work |
full | every craft that touches the work | 3 | all, debated | one-shot, expensive or public work, and only when the user asks for it |
Never seat a craft that has nothing to look at. A silent film has no sound room. A piece with no added elements has no VFX room.
Register
Every lens is tagged universal, luxury, comedy-doc or on request. The chair reads the register from the brief before casting, and only matching and universal lenses are eligible. A quiet film for a wedding venue is not reviewed by mockumentary specialists, and a deadpan comedy is not reviewed by fashion photographers. cast.md has the rules.
The run
Everything is written to screening/<run-name>/ in the working directory. Each step reads only the files named for it. That rule is what keeps a run inside its limits, so do not widen it.
| Step | Who | Reads | Writes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0. Brief | chair (you) | the user's material, templates/brief.md, screening/DECISIONS.md if present | 00-brief.md |
| 1. Cast | chair | brief, lenses/index.md, cast.md | 01-cast.md |
| 2. Observe | one observer | brief, every image, frame or clip, rounds/observe.md | 02-observations.md |
| 3. Rooms | one agent per craft | brief, observations, one craft file from lenses/, rounds/room.md | rooms/<craft>.md |
| 4. Ledger | chair | every room file, rounds/ledger.md | 03-ledger.md |
| 5. Disputes | one agent per conflict | brief, observations, that conflict's rows, the lenses named in them, rounds/dispute.md | disputes/<n>.md |
| 6. Final | writer | brief, observations, ledger, dispute rulings, rounds/verdict.md | 04-final.md |
| 7. Skeptic | a fresh agent | brief, observations, final, rounds/skeptic.md | 05-skeptic.md |
| 8. Close | chair | skeptic report | fixes to 04-final.md, new lines in screening/DECISIONS.md |
Step 2 is skipped when there is nothing to look at, and the brief says so.
Running inside limits
- Resume, never restart. Before each step, check whether its output file already exists and is complete. If it is, skip it. A run interrupted by a limit continues from the first missing file.
- Three at a time. If you can run subagents, run at most three room or dispute agents together, then the next three. If you cannot, play each room yourself, one after another, finishing and saving each file before starting the next.
- Tier the models where the harness allows it: a smaller, cheaper model for rooms and the observer, the strongest model for disputes, the final and the skeptic.
- Give each agent paths, not pasted content. Its instruction is: read these files, follow this round file, write that file. Rooms do not see other rooms.
- Images are read once. Only the observer opens images by default. A room opens an image itself only when its craft judges pixels (colorist, cinematographer, VFX, costume) and the observations are not enough.
- Keep to the word limits in each round file.
After the run
Reply to the user with:
- The final version, complete and ready to use.
- What changed, in five lines or fewer.
- Each dispute and how it was ruled, one line each, with the dissent.
- What the skeptic found and what was done about it.
- What the panel could not judge.
Then say where the files are. Do not paste room files into the reply.
Files in this skill
cast.md: how to choose crafts and lenses.lenses/index.md: one line per lens with its role and register, for casting.lenses/<craft>.md: the full cards for one craft.rounds/*.md: the instruction for each step.templates/brief.md: the brief to fill in.