Brand voice guide and rewrite
A voice guide is useful only if two different writers who follow it produce copy a reader can't tell apart. So every trait comes with a do and a don't taken from real sentences, and the guide is proven by rewriting one draft in it. Voice is the personality that stays the same; tone is how it shifts with the reader's situation (Mailchimp's style guide: "the same voice all the time, but your tone changes").
When to use
- A team has a few pieces of copy it likes and wants new copy to match them.
- Writers, freelancers, or AI drafts sound like different companies.
- Someone shares a draft and asks to "make it sound like us".
- Not for inventing a brand from nothing with no samples: ask for 3 texts the team likes, even from other companies.
What you need
- 3 to 5 sample texts the team says sound right: web pages, emails, posts, support replies. Fewer than 3: ask once for more; if none come, proceed and mark the guide "[assumption: based on 2 samples]".
- Optional: 1 text that sounds wrong to them. A negative sample sharpens every "don't".
- Optional: a draft to rewrite. If none, write the guide only.
- Who the reader is (buyer role, how technical). If missing, infer it from the samples and say so.
Steps
- Read for patterns, not adjectives. Measure what the samples actually do: average sentence length, how often they use "you" vs "we", contractions, questions, numbers, jargon, exclamation marks, how sentences open. Write the numbers down; "short sentences" means nothing until you say "12 words on average".
- Place the samples on the 4 tone dimensions. Nielsen Norman Group's dimensions: formal vs casual, serious vs funny, respectful vs irreverent, matter-of-fact vs enthusiastic. Say where the samples sit on each; NN/g warns against the extreme end of every dimension.
- Name 3 to 4 traits. Each trait is a "this, not that" pair, the form Mailchimp's guide uses ("smart but not snobbish"): "Direct, not blunt", "Expert, not academic". Our default is 4 at most, because nobody remembers more. If two traits produce the same edits, merge them.
- Prove each trait with a do and a don't. The "do" is a sentence quoted from the samples. The "don't" is the same idea written the wrong way. If you can't quote a sample for a trait, drop the trait.
- Build the word list. Words they use (product terms, verbs they repeat), words they avoid (jargon, hype, words the samples never use where competitors do). 8 to 15 entries per side. Include how they name the product and the customer.
- Write the mechanics and the tone shifts. Headline case, numerals vs words, Oxford comma, emoji, exclamation marks, contractions, greeting and sign-off. Only list what the samples settle; mark the rest "not decided". Add 1 line on how tone shifts for bad news (an outage, a price rise): same traits, less humor, more plain.
- Rewrite the draft. Keep every fact and claim; change only wording, order, and length. Then list the 3 to 5 biggest changes with the trait each one serves, so the writer learns the guide instead of just getting new copy.
- Flag what voice can't fix. If the draft lacks proof, a clear offer, or a reader, say so in one line. Don't hide a weak message under a good tone.
Output format
# [Brand] voice guide
**Reader:** [who we write for, in one line]
**Based on:** [list of samples]
## Traits
| We are | Not | Do (from samples) | Don't |
|---|---|---|---|
| [trait] | [overdone version] | "[quoted sentence]" | "[same idea, wrong]" |
## Sentence habits
- Average sentence: [n] words. Longest allowed: [n].
- [you/we ratio, contractions, questions, numbers]
## Words
| Use | Avoid |
|---|---|
| [word] | [word] — [why] |
## Tone dimensions
Formal–casual: [where] · Serious–funny: [where] · Respectful–irreverent: [where] · Matter-of-fact–enthusiastic: [where]
## Mechanics
- [headline case, numerals, punctuation, emoji, sign-off; "not decided" where samples don't settle it]
- Bad news: [how tone shifts]
## Rewrite
**Before:** [draft]
**After:** [rewrite]
**What changed**
1. [change] — [trait]
**Voice can't fix:** [missing proof/offer, or "nothing"]
Example
Input: 3 samples from Fernway, a payroll app for restaurants: the home page, an onboarding email, and 1 support reply. Lines from them: "Payday shouldn't eat your Sunday." "Run payroll in 4 minutes from your phone." "Tips split by hours worked, automatically." Counted across the full samples: sentences average 9 words, the longest has 18, and "you" appears 3 times as often as "we". All 3 use contractions, sentence-case headlines, and numerals for numbers, with no emoji and no questions in headlines. Draft to rewrite: "Fernway is a comprehensive, innovative payroll solution that empowers restaurant owners to streamline their operations."
Output:
# Fernway voice guide
**Reader:** Restaurant owners and managers, not finance people [assumption: inferred from the samples; confirm with the team].
**Based on:** home page, onboarding email, 1 support reply
## Traits
| We are | Not | Do (from samples) | Don't |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plain | Dumbed down | "Run payroll in 4 minutes from your phone." | "Process compensation disbursements efficiently." |
| On their side | Chummy | "Payday shouldn't eat your Sunday." | "Hey friend! We've got your back!!" |
| Specific | Number-stuffed | "Tips split by hours worked, automatically." | "Advanced tip allocation capabilities." |
## Sentence habits
- Across the full samples, not just the lines quoted above: average sentence 9 words; longest allowed 18.
- "You" appears 3 times as often as "we". Contractions always. No questions in headlines.
## Words
| Use | Avoid |
|---|---|
| payday, run payroll | solution, operations — say nothing |
| tips, split | empower, streamline — hype verbs |
| hours worked, automatically | comprehensive, innovative — claims with no proof |
| from your phone, you (never "restaurant owners") | compensation, capabilities — finance and software jargon |
## Tone dimensions
Fairly casual · Mostly serious, light humor in headlines · Respectful · Matter-of-fact
## Mechanics
- Sentence case headlines. Numerals for all numbers. No emoji. Oxford comma: not decided.
- Bad news: drop the humor, keep the short sentences.
## Rewrite
**Before:** Fernway is a comprehensive, innovative payroll solution that empowers restaurant owners to streamline their operations.
**After:** Fernway runs payroll for your restaurant, start to finish.
**What changed**
1. "Payroll solution" became what it does: "runs payroll" — Plain
2. "Restaurant owners" became "your restaurant" — On their side
3. "Comprehensive" became "start to finish"; "innovative" and "streamline their operations" were cut, as they claim nothing a reader can check — Specific
**Voice can't fix:** proof. The draft gives no number. The samples' "Run payroll in 4 minutes from your phone." would fit if it holds for this page [check: the 4-minute claim applies here].
Checks before you send
- Every "do" is a sentence quoted from a sample, not written by you.
- 3 or 4 traits, each a "this, not that" pair.
- Sentence habits include at least 2 measured numbers, and all 4 tone dimensions are placed.
- The rewrite keeps every fact in the draft and adds none.
- Each listed change names the trait it serves.
Common mistakes
- Traits like "friendly, professional, innovative". Every company claims them; they change no sentence.
- Rewriting into your own house style instead of the samples'. Recheck sentence length against the measured average.
- Adding claims during the rewrite to make it punchier. Voice changes wording, never facts.